Key Takeaways: My Water Filter vs. Aquasana
The Core Problem: Unfiltered shower water often contains chlorine and other contaminants that can lead to dry skin, brittle hair and faded hair colour. A shower filter is the best solution.
The Core Decision: This comparison comes down to the My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter, which excels in style and long-term value, versus the Aquasana Premium Shower Filter, which leads with official NSF certification and system flexibility.
Choose My Water Filter if: You prioritise a sleek, all-metal design that matches modern tapware and a lower overall cost of ownership.
Choose Aquasana if: You value the peace of mind of third-party NSF certification and want the option of an all-in-one system with a shower head or wand.
Table of Contents
Shower Filter Showdown: A Guide to Your Best Shower Ever
When you step out of the shower, do you notice your skin feeling tight and itchy? Does your hair feel dry and brittle after a bath, or is your expensive salon hair colour fading too quickly? The culprit is likely the water your use to shower.
That daily shower exposes your skin and hair to chemicals like chlorine, which can strip away natural oils. The great news is that a high-quality shower filter is a simple, affordable solution to transform your daily routine. Today, we are comparing two of our most popular and effective options to help you decide.
The Contenders:
The My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter: Our high-performance, stylish and value-packed solution.
The Aquasana Premium Shower Filter: A globally recognised brand known for its certified performance.
This guide provides a side-by-side, honest comparison to help you confidently choose the perfect filter for your bathroom, budget and family.
At-a-Glance: Quick Comparison Table
|
Feature |
My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter |
Aquasana Premium Shower Filter |
|
Filtration Media |
KDF-55, Calcium Sulphite & GAC |
Patented Copper/Zinc (KDF-55) & Coconut Shell Carbon |
|
Key Contaminants |
Removes Chlorine, Iron Oxides and Hydrogen Sulphide, and Inhibits Bacterial Growth |
Reduces 90%+ of Chlorine, Synthetic Chemicals, VOCs |
|
Filter Lifespan |
Approx. 6 months |
Approx. 6 months or 38,000 litres |
|
Certifications |
High-quality, tested components |
NSF Certified to Standards 42 & 61 |
|
Design & Finish |
Sleek, all-chrome metal housing |
White plastic housing |
|
System Options |
Single filter unit (fits any shower head) |
Filter-only or system with shower head/wand |
|
Installation |
DIY, no tools required |
DIY, no tools required |
|
Initial Price |
$59.99 |
$154.99 (Filter only) |
|
Replacement Cost |
$42.99 |
$99.99 |
|
Best For |
Style-conscious, value-driven users |
Users prioritising NSF certification |
Detailed Comparison: Feature by Feature
Let's explore what these features mean for your daily shower.
Filtration Technology & Performance
Both units excel at removing chlorine, but they use different methods.
My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter:
This filter uses a robust, 12-stage process for comprehensive performance.
KDF-55: Exceptional at removing chlorine and heavy metals in hot water.
Granular Activated Carbon (GAC): A powerhouse for grabbing chlorine and other chemical contaminants.
Calcium Sulphite: Ensures chlorine removal is fast and highly efficient.
Aquasana Premium Shower Filter:
This filter uses a unique 2-stage system backed by rigorous third-party testing.
Patented Media: A combination of Copper/Zinc (KDF-55) and coconut shell carbon reduces over 90% of chlorine, plus other synthetic chemicals and VOCs.
Unique Up-Flow Design: Prevents clogging and ensures maximum water-to-filter contact time.
NSF Certified: Verified by an independent third party to meet NSF/ANSI Standards 42 and 61 for its contaminant-reduction claims.
The Takeaway: The Aquasana shower filter offers the peace of mind of official NSF certification. Meanwhille, the My Water Filter shower filter uses a comprehensive 12-stage media combination for robust, all-around performance.
Design, Aesthetics & Installation
My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter:
The standout feature is its premium, all-chrome metal housing. It's durable, solid and designed to look like a permanent, high-end fixture that seamlessly matches modern tapware.
Aquasana Premium Shower Filter:
This filter offers flexibility. The standard unit is a classic white plastic housing, but you can also buy it as a complete system that includes a convenient handheld wand.
Installation: Both shower filters are incredibly simple. You do not need a plumber. Installation is a tool-free, DIY job that takes less than five minutes.
Long-Term Cost of Ownership
A smart purchase considers the total cost over time. Here is the transparent breakdown:
|
Cost Analysis |
My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter |
Aquasana Premium Shower Filter |
|
Initial Investment |
$59.99 |
$154.99 |
|
Replacement Cartridge |
$42.99 |
$99.99 |
|
Year 1 Total Cost |
$102.98 ($59.99 shower filter + one $42.99 cartridge) |
$254.98 ($154.99 shower filter + one $99.99 cartridge) |
|
Annual Cost (Year 2+) |
$85.98 |
$199.98 |
(Prices are subject to change. Based on replacing the cartridge every 6 months.)
The Value Proposition: The My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter offers a significantly lower initial and ongoing cost, presenting a fantastic long-term value. The higher cost of the Aquasana is tied to its NSF certification, global brand recognition and all-in-one system options.
Who Should Buy Which Filter?
This is the deciding factor. Find your perfect match below:
Choose the My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter if:
✅ Aesthetics are a top priority. You want a durable, all-metal chrome filter that looks like a permanent, high-end fixture.
✅ You value simplicity. You want a single, powerful unit that works perfectly with your existing shower head.
✅ You're budget-conscious. You are looking for fantastic performance with a significantly lower long-term cost.
✅ You prefer supporting local. You like the idea of buying a product championed by an Australian water filtration company.
Choose the Aquasana Premium Shower Filter if:
✅ Third-party certification is non-negotiable. You want the ultimate peace of mind of an NSF-certified product.
✅ You want an all-in-one system. You are interested in upgrading to the optional massaging shower head or handheld wand.
✅ Brand recognition matters. You prefer a globally established and widely reviewed brand in water filtration.
✅ You're targeting specific chemicals. Aquasana's certified performance against a broad range of synthetic chemicals is important to you.
Conclusion: Your Best Shower Awaits
There is no single "best" shower filter—only the best one for your specific needs. The decision boils down to the sleek design and fantastic value of the My Water Filter versus the certified performance and system flexibility of the Aquasana.
Whichever you choose, you are making a brilliant investment in the health of your skin and hair.
Unfiltered shower water often contains chlorine and other chemicals that can lead to dry skin, brittle hair and faded hair colour, which a quality shower filter can resolve.
The My Water Filter Chrome Shower Filter is presented as the ideal choice for those prioritising a stylish, all-metal design and excellent long-term value, with a lower initial and ongoing cost.
The Aquasana Premium Shower Filter is recommended for individuals who value the assurance of official NSF certification for contaminant reduction and desire the flexibility of an all-in-one system with an optional shower head or wand.
Hear From Our Satisfied Customers
How Do I Know When to Change the Filter Cartridge?
The recommended lifespan for both is approximately 6 months. You'll also know it's time if you notice the smell of chlorine returning or if your skin and hair start to feel dry again.
Will a Shower Filter Reduce My Water Pressure?
Both filters are engineered for high flow rates. Any impact on water pressure is minimal and typically unnoticeable.
Can I Install These Shower Filters Myself?
Absolutely. Both are designed for a simple, tool-free DIY installation that takes less than 5 minutes. No plumber is required.
Do These Filters Soften Hard Water?
They are not water softeners, but they do reduce scale-forming minerals. This makes water feel softer on your skin and reduces limescale buildup on your shower screen and fixtures.
